Pyrite vs Gold
Pyrite has been called fool's gold for four centuries for a reason: in the right light the resemblance is genuinely good. These five tests separate them in under a minute, and none of them needs equipment.
1. Streak
Drag the specimen across unglazed porcelain. Gold leaves a golden-yellow streak. Pyrite leaves greenish-black. This test alone is decisive and it is the first one to run.
2. Malleability
Press a point into a small area with a steel pin. Gold deforms — it dents, bends and flattens. Pyrite is brittle and shatters into angular fragments. Metals bend; sulphides break.
3. Crystal shape
Pyrite grows in sharp geometric forms: cubes, often with fine parallel striations on the faces, and twelve-sided pyritohedra. Gold rarely shows visible crystals in nature. It occurs as irregular nuggets, flakes, wires and dendritic growths with rounded, lumpy outlines.
4. Hardness
Pyrite is 6 to 6.5 on the Mohs scale — it will scratch glass and resist a steel knife. Gold is 2.5 to 3 — softer than a copper coin, and a knife marks it easily. If your "gold" scratches glass, it is not gold.
5. Weight
Gold has a specific gravity around 19.3. Pyrite is about 5.0. A gold nugget feels startlingly heavy — roughly four times the heft of a pyrite piece of the same size. Once you have held real gold, this test becomes instant.
Summary table
| Pyrite | Gold | |
|---|---|---|
| Streak | Greenish-black | Golden yellow |
| Behaviour | Brittle, shatters | Malleable, dents |
| Shape | Cubes, striated faces | Nuggets, flakes, wires |
| Hardness | 6–6.5 | 2.5–3 |
| Specific gravity | ~5.0 | ~19.3 |
| Colour in shade | Brassy, slightly green | Rich yellow, unchanged |
The third candidate nobody mentions
Chalcopyrite is also brassy and is mistaken for both. It is softer than pyrite (3.5–4), often shows an iridescent purple-blue tarnish, and has a greenish-black streak. If a brassy mineral is soft but still streaks dark, chalcopyrite is the likely answer.
Try Stonescout
Take a photo and Stonescout suggests what it might be, shows its properties and keeps your finds in one collection. Free on iPhone and Android.